Controversy struck yesterday during the penalty shootout between Atlético Madrid and Real Madrid. Both sides played to a 1-1 draw, forcing the match into extra time.

Julián Álvarez’s goal during the shootout was ruled out for an adjudged double touch after he slipped while taking the penalty. According to CBS Sports Golazo, Álvarez’s penalty was disallowed by semi-automated technology.

Álvarez reportedly told his camp, as per international journalist Pedro Fullana, that he does not feel he touched the ball twice and that he intended to place it where he did. The journalist also stated that there are no clear images of the incident and that refereeing experts have many doubts. The situation is currently being analyzed by Atlético Madrid, who are deciding whether to ask UEFA for an explanation, the report concluded.

Another report from Spanish journalist Rubén Uría confirmed that Atlético Madrid has officially requested clarification from UEFA regarding Álvarez’s disallowed goal. UEFA is considering issuing a statement on the matter. Once UEFA makes a decision, Atlético will take the appropriate measures.

Former German referee Manuel Gräfe also weighed in on the incident, saying: “Was that clear and obvious enough to disallow Álvarez’s goal? Was it a simultaneous double touch or one touch? It feels wrong to disallow in a shootout.”

According to FIFA Laws, Rule 13 (p.122) states that it is forbidden for the kicker to touch the ball twice before another player does. However, FIFA Rule 9 clarifies that this only applies if the ball is in play. Additionally, it is only considered a second touch if the ball clearly moves (FIFA Rule 13, p.122 – Ball Pt2).

Atlético Madrid’s head coach, Diego Simeone, expressed his frustration during the post-match press conference, stating: “To anyone here: raise your hand if you saw that Julián touched the ball twice in the penalty. Come on! And? Ready? Nobody raises theirs. Another question.”

He also added: “I’ve never seen VAR call to review a penalty in a shootout.”

The incident has sparked debate, as many neutrals have never witnessed a penalty being ruled out during a shootout after 120 minutes of action. However, controversial decisions in football are not uncommon.